jab8356

Dual boot (XP & 7) SSD TRIM question

8 posts in this topic

Hi, I'm new here so if this has been asked already, please forgive me. I did some looking around and didn't see what I'm looking for. I want to build a new machine with my first SSD. I would like to have 2 partitions on the SSD and put Windows XP on one partition and Windows 7 on the other. I know that TRIM is not built into XP, but it is in 7. The machine would be run in Windows 7 95% of the time. My question is would Windows 7 do TRIM on the XP partition when 7 is running? The drive I think I would like to buy is a Samsung 840 pro 256 GB. I know their magician software will maintain the drive in XP, but if 7 will do it while it is running, then I don't see the need to run magician. Thanks in advance!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TRIM is normally done after the OS permanently deletes a file, so Windows 7 won't send TRIM commands for files that were deleted under a different OS. You would still need to run the Magician software occasionally within XP.

Trying to install Windows 7 and XP on the same SSD sounds like a recipe for all sorts of problems with alignment (for XP), incompatible bootloaders, and corrupted file permissions if you try to share data between partitions. I think it would be much better to give the whole SSD to Win7 and install XP on a separate drive, and share data with a third drive. Better yet, use Virtualbox.

Edited by dietrc70

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Trying to install Windows 7 and XP on the same SSD sounds like a recipe for all sorts of problems with alignment (for XP), incompatible bootloaders, and corrupted file permissions if you try to share data between partitions. I think it would be much better to give the whole SSD to Win7 and install XP on a separate drive, and share data with a third drive. Better yet, use Virtualbox.

I was planning on using the Windows 7 install DVD to partition the drive so it will be aligned properly and then install XP. Data will be on a separate HDD. Does this still sound like trouble?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was planning on using the Windows 7 install DVD to partition the drive so it will be aligned properly and then install XP. Data will be on a separate HDD. Does this still sound like trouble?

There's a particular procedure you need to follow to get both Win 7 and XP to boot from the same HD. I can't remember it offhand, but you can probably find it easily if you search for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There's a particular procedure you need to follow to get both Win 7 and XP to boot from the same HD. I can't remember it offhand, but you can probably find it easily if you search for it.

I have done a dual boot with my current machine on a HDD. Install XP first on one partition and then 7 on the other. The Win 7 installer created a boot menu where I select which OS I want to boot into. I would imagine it is the same for an SSD except I have to use the Win 7 setup disc to partition the SSD first so it is aligned correctly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both XP and W7 on my Samsung 840 Pro on my SSD. I just migrated the partitions from the hard disk to the SSD.

If you have boot problems on one of them, use EasyBCD. This is also a precious tool to have available when you want to multiboot and the Windows you install is a prior version to the one(s) already installed.

Since XP does not handle alignment, use Minitool Partition Wizard Home (it's free): it will align ANY partition already present! Please remember that all partitions on SSD should be aligned for performance reasons.

Edited by Gswiss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both XP and W7 on my Samsung 840 Pro on my SSD. I just migrated the partitions from the hard disk to the SSD.

If you have boot problems on one of them, use EasyBCD. This is also a precious tool to have available when you want to multiboot and the Windows you install is a prior version to the one(s) already installed. I used it quite often to install XP alongside pre-installed Vista, also W7 or XP alongside preinstalled W8 which is a dud (only 6-7% users worlwide after practically a year on the market). Thus, you can install XP alongside pre-installed W7. As mentioned somewhere above, google for the procedure which is simple. Otherwise, report back.

Since XP does not handle alignment, use Minitool Partition Wizard Home (it's free): it will align ANY partition already present! Please remember that all partitions on SSD should be aligned for performance reasons.

Edited by Gswiss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used my Win 7 install disc to partition the drive into two partitions, then I installed XP on one and 7 on the other. I checked the alignment and it is good. I do use EasyBCD too. Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now