• Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

0 Neutral

About jwb

  • Rank
  1. Supermicro has been selling hotswap SAS racks for this form factor for about a year. For example the CSE-M28E1 holds 8 2.5" SAS disks (or SATA) disks.
  2. I would try the WD RE2 500GB disk instead. In my experience you get far more IOPS from these disks than from Seagate 7200.9. I think the WD copes better with being in a rack full of disks (something the Seagate Cheetah series also does well).
  3. jwb

    HDD coolers - harmfull?

    If the cooler has a fan and the fan is hard-coupled to the drive and the fan vibrates, this could certainly lead to short life and degraded performance. Also, driver coolers are stupid. Drives are perfectly capable of cooling themselves if mounted properly, which is to say vertically. Mount them horizontally, and they are sure to cook themselves.
  4. jwb

    Areca 1260 Native PCI-E or Bridged?

    I know this is an old thread, but I just had to correct the wrongness here. Post #3 is wrong: the Areca cards are not "native" PCI-Express. The other posts are correct: it doesn't matter. The Intel CPU used on the Areca controller has a PCI-Express bridge with two PCI-X busses. The controller itself is on one PCI-X bus, and the other is unused. The performance impact of the signalling bridge is indistinguishable from zero. If you though it was a problem, you'd probably be really upset about the HyperTransport-to-PCI-Express bridge, right?
  5. Most of the replies in this thread are incorrect, with the exception of #7. You can get SATA port multipliers, and these are supported in the SATA-II protocol level. I have one of these that I am experimenting with, a 5-port multiplier, and it has so far worked flawlessly on an Areca 8-port RAID controller and Seagate disks.
  6. I'd like to see the 12V and 5V current listed separately. It will be very helpful when building machines. I'm building a machine now with 15 disks, and Seagate's documentation of max current consumption on the 7200.8 is just plainly incorrect. Some science will be nice. SCIENCE!
  7. Any word on server benchmarks? Your average queue lengths are so short that I'm sure the desktop storagemark is totally unrelated to my database and fileserver workloads.
  8. Atlas 10K V 300GB. It's a nice big, fast disk but helloooo price tag. Guess I'll hold off on building the 800-node Lustre filesystem from these...
  9. Okay, lots of stuff to respond to. The driver only "comes with" the SATA adapter if you are trapped in the Windows prison. On Linux, FreeBSD, et al the driver authors and the hardware vendors are orthogonal. So it's possible to have command queueing even if the Windows driver does not support same. Secondly, I think it is too bad that software RAID wasn't tested. Quiz: what makes a better RAID processor, 1) an Opteron 244, or 2) an Intel i960? If you picked 1, you picked correctly. And the Mylex 170, what a dog. It does not exactly have a reputation for speed. Software RAIDs will blow its proverbial doors off. Also it is easy to disable or limit command queueing on some SCSI HBAs. On Adaptec HBAs the depth can be clamped anywhere between 0 and 255, on a per-target basis. I do take some minor issue with how the article is presented, especially its conclusions. I think the definition of single-user or desktop user is vague. Many people do absurd operations on their personal computers that would make some servers blush. I personally have a PostgreSQL database that exceeds a terabyte, and I like to compile very large trees of software. I use a RAID5, because I dislike losing my data, and there is a significant benefit to compile time from the RAID setup. The RAID5 setup also improves performance on metadata-intensive workloads, like tar/untar or cvs update. Finally, thanks for a nice article with some good hard data.
  10. jwb

    Why Are People Buying S-ata?

    The "rounded" PATA cables are a signal integrity nightmare. I won't even allow them in my office, even in desktop computers. The main buyer of these cables must be people with no understand of electromagnetism at all.
  11. You are going to have to be a little more specific. How is the RAID attached? SCSI? What kind of HBA? What hardware platform specifically? How does the machine boot? From CD, DVD, network?
  12. jwb

    Recertified Cheetah 15k.3

    I used to know a fellow who worked on the assembly line at Seagate's integration factory in Oklahoma City. Based on the stories he told of how failed, but new, devices were repaired by hand and sent out as new, I'd be inclined to trust a refurbished device just as much as a new one. Also I agree with the upthread poster. I have piles of failed Hitachis and Fujitsus, but not a single failed Seagate SCSI drive.
  13. jwb

    Your Worst Drive Failure?

    Once I had a SCSI raid set that was mirrored in pairs like this: 0,1:2,3:4,5:6,7 Each pair was a RAID 1. The data was my company's entire collected research, for which there existed no current backup. Well anyway, disk 0 failed so I pulled it. Lo and behold the next day the host, which had been running for at least a year, needed a reboot. So I rebooted it. Unfortunately the RAID driver decided it needed to resync the arrays. It was performing the resync thusly: 1 -> 2 : 3 -> 4 : 5 -> 6 I wouldn't have noticed except there was no activity on device 7. Luckily I still had a good copy of each mirror, on devices 1, 3, 5, and 7. Needless to say I cut the power in a panic once I got finished scratching my head. Then I unmounted the four good devices, set the hardware read-only jumper, and mirrored them on my administrative desktop. Definitely a heart-attack moment.
  14. jwb

    Why Are People Buying S-ata?

    I started buying SATA disks in my datacenter at work. SCSI is just ridiculous $/GB these days and, although I still need SCSI for the absolute highest performance applications, the WD Raptor is a very fast disk and suffices in all other locations. With the 3Ware SATA controllers I get 12 SATA ports per PCI-X slot and the mainboards I've been using have 4 SATA ports as well. I have no driver problems with the 3Ware because they are identical to the 3Ware PATA controller cards as far as the host is concerned. We're talking $550 for 12 ports which is comparable to PCI-X u320 adapters. Supermicro offers chassis with hot-swap SATA bays and backplanes. I think these are great. I expect to take delivery of one this week in fact, and I'm going to jam 4x74GB Raptors and 4x400GB Hitachi disks in that sucker. With PATA I wouldn't have this nice hotswap case and I'd have a lot more cable clutter. I don't ever want to see a host with 16 PATA ports, thanks.
  15. jwb

    300gb Scsi Drive

    Incorrect. It uses 4-platters as do all 10K SCSI drives of its generation. This information is easily found on their website. You're a smart one, eh? http://www.hgst.com/hdd/support/dk/3/32ej14spec.html "Number of Disks: 5" Cheers.