How problems manifest w/ too long eSATA cables?
Posted 23 June 2010 - 12:52 AM
By too long I don't necessarily mean out-of-spec length (I suppose the spec is a recommendation in which it's more likely to stay within the required electrical specs), but also factors like cable quality (shielding, impedance, whatever), connectors, and electrical tolerances of the devices at both ends.
I have an external eSATA enclosure that came with a 1m cable which is way too short and a real hindrance. The spec allows for 2m, so I want to get something longer. My assumption is that they included something that short (1m is the max for internal SATA) as a way to minimize problems with all the non-spec hardware floating around; internal SATA connectors used as external, brackets to repurpose internal to external, pre-standard external devices, etc.
Hopefully my hardware is to spec, and not just by looks (the connectors, at least, are true eSATA), but I have no way of knowing.
Posted 23 June 2010 - 09:36 AM
I suspect the real reason the enclosure came with a 1-meter cable is cost and most users would just set the external unit next to the PC, so a longer cable just gets in the way.
Posted 24 June 2010 - 12:29 AM
Re limited cable length, extra 50-100cm of eSATA cable would only be a few more cents. I'm using it next to a PC, a full tower on the floor, and it's barely enough. Combined with a short 1m electricity cable there's no way for me to use it at all without an extension cord. Whatever the reason for skimping on cables, I'm disappointed with Vantec.
Posted 24 June 2010 - 03:27 AM
What some people do is attach a "SATA to eSata" "adapter" from their motherboard's regular SATA port to a bracket for the back of their case. There is a key difference between SATA and eSata where eSata sends a higher voltage through the cable to allow for the longer length.
So even if you use in spec long eSata cables in this scenario, there is no guarantee.
Posted 24 June 2010 - 08:28 AM
As mentioned, I bet Vantec included a 1-m cable since that's what most folks would need and it's the cheapest type to provide. If enclosure manufacturers are like HDD manufacturers, every penny saved is worth chasing. At least longer eSATA cables are relatively easy to find. I had the misfortune recently of needing 2-m long mini-SAS to 4X SAS cables. I ended up custom ordering those.
Posted 24 June 2010 - 04:05 PM
I think there's no voltage difference, but there are different tolerances specified for the end devices.
There is a key difference between SATA and eSata where eSata sends a higher voltage through the cable to allow for the longer length.
That's fine if you have error correction kicking in. The question is whether there could be undetected errors.
I imagine throughput issues would be due to additional ECC necessary to correct the bad data passing through the cable.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users